Carl R. Trueman's new book, 'To Change All Worlds: Critical Theory From Marx to Marcuse,' explores the history, foundations, and goals of critical theory. Trueman's approach aims to understand critical theory rather than argue against it, drawing comparisons to C.S. Lewis's work. Critical theory, as defined by Trueman, encompasses various approaches to cultural analysis, often with Marxist or post-structuralist origins. A common goal of critical theory is to challenge the status quo by exposing power dynamics and manipulations within societal norms. Critical theory addresses anthropological questions by examining how the understanding of humanity has evolved across time and cultures.
5 months ago
Critical theory encompasses a variety of approaches to cultural analysis, all sharing the common goal of destabilizing the status quo and unmasking power dynamics inherent in morality, social practices, and political categories 1. Carl R. Trueman's book, "To Change All Worlds: Critical Theory From Marx to Marcuse," explores its history, foundations, and objectives without resorting to polemics 1.
The Frankfurt School, including figures like Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno, and Herbert Marcuse, were pivotal in the early development of critical theory 1. These scholars, often from privileged Jewish backgrounds, were deeply concerned with understanding why the German working class supported Nazism and how a culturally sophisticated nation could descend into barbarism 1. They revised the Marxist project by focusing on consciousness and how societies create and manipulate cultural understanding, coining terms like "the culture industry" to describe systems shaping public thought 1.
A central concern of critical theory is the question of what it means to be human, shifting the inquiry from "What is man?" to "Who benefits from defining 'man' in this way?" 1. This approach acknowledges that understandings of human nature have evolved across time and cultures, and that normative definitions can be used to justify oppression, such as race-based slavery 1.
However, a significant critique from a Christian perspective is that critical theory tends to reduce categories like "human nature" solely to manipulative power relations 1. This stands in opposition to the Christian belief in human beings as ontologically made in the image of God 1.
Trueman notes that critical theory, particularly the Frankfurt School, insightfully frames questions about the human condition and legitimately raises concerns about the objectification of persons 1. It correctly identifies how modern society, through mass bureaucracies, employer-employee relations, and even aspects of the sexual revolution, can treat individuals as mere instruments rather than unique subjects 1.
Despite these valid observations, critical theory is seen as failing to offer compelling answers to the anthropological questions it raises 1. While it often identifies capitalism or societal systems as the root cause of objectification, a Christian perspective posits that the ultimate problem lies within the fallen human heart 1. Therefore, the solution is found in Christ and grace, not in economic or political revolution 1.
The modern manifestation of critical theory is rooted in several key historical shifts 1. These include the increasing prioritization of inner feelings as definitive of human identity, a shift in political focus from economic to psychological concerns, and the emergence of the "rebel" or "transgressor" as a cultural hero 1. This emphasis on perpetual iconoclasm, rather than tradition, aligns with the ethos of technological innovation, fostering a world of constant flux 1.
Critical theory also profoundly influenced the sexual revolution by historicizing Freud's insights on sexual codes 1. It argued that specific sexual codes supported particular forms of society and oppression, suggesting that shattering traditional codes (like monogamous, heterosexual marriage) was necessary to overthrow oppressive systems 1. While the economic underpinnings of this argument may have diminished, the idea that sexual codes are inherently oppressive remains a staple of modern politics 1.
For Christians engaging with critical theory, Trueman advises a careful and informed approach 1. It is crucial to read and understand the sources in their historical context, acknowledging the legitimacy of the questions critical theory poses without being intimidated 1.
Christians should recognize that critical theory asks important questions that demand careful answers 1. By demonstrating the inadequacy of critical theory's proposed solutions and offering more robust, Christ-centered alternatives regarding human nature, how people should treat each other, and why they fail to do so, Christians can provide a better path forward 1. Dismissing or polemically attacking critical theory without proper understanding hinders the ability to offer a superior alternative 1.
How does the Church view societal power structures?
The Catholic Church views societal power structures through the lens of its social teaching, emphasizing principles such as the dignity of the human person, the common good, subsidiarity, and solidarity . This teaching has evolved over time, particularly in response to societal changes like the Industrial Revolution, which highlighted deep divisions between rich and poor .
The Church's social teaching can be understood as an obligation for every individual to contribute to the good of society, aiming for justice and prioritizing the "option for the poor" . This approach seeks to foster human fulfillment for everyone, ensuring that each individual benefits from living in an orderly, prosperous, and healthy society . A society that disregards the common good is seen as unpleasant, dangerous, and unjust to those it excludes .
Key aspects of the Church's view on societal power structures include:
The foundation of the Church's social teaching is the inherent dignity of every human person . This dignity is rooted in the belief that each individual is made in the image and likeness of God, possessing an intrinsic value that can never be lost or ignored . Therefore, any societal power structure must respect and honor this fundamental dignity, ensuring that no human being is exploited or subordinated to other interests .
The concept of the common good is central to the Church's understanding of society . It refers to the conditions that allow all people, individually and in groups, to reach their fulfillment more fully and more easily. The Church believes that democracy and human rights are necessary for the common good, though neither can be taken for granted . True peace and the common good are intimately linked to justice, both within a community and globally .
Solidarity means that all individuals are responsible for one another . It is defined as "the firm and persevering determination to commit oneself to the common good—that is to say, to the good of all and of each individual, because we are all really responsible for all" . This principle calls for individuals and groups to work together, directing their common efforts towards expressing love for their homeland and fostering interdependence . The Church encourages Catholics to imbue political, social, and cultural institutions with the spirit of genuine social solidarity .
The Church has a strong commitment to the poor and defenseless, especially exploited workers . The "preferential option for the poor" is a core aspect of its social teaching, emphasizing that Christian consciences must be awakened to a true sense of concern for the poor, oppressed, weak, and defenseless . This option is not merely a humanitarian concern but is deeply nourished by prayer and liturgical worship, drawing strength from union with Christ for service and justice .
The Church has historically critiqued economic determinism, whether in the form of Marxism (left) or unlimited free-market capitalism (laissez-faire economics) (right) . It seeks a society of "free work, of enterprise and of participation," aiming to overcome the deficiencies of both socialist and capitalist systems . The Church insists that the mobilization of resources and potential must always be guided by a moral understanding, ensuring fairness and just distribution of efforts and sacrifices among various social groups .
The Church views its social teaching as an integral part of its moral teaching and evangelization . Proclaiming social justice, even when dealing with deeply embedded social structures, is seen as a form of evangelization . The Church's commitment to social teaching is not separate from its mission to preach the Gospel; rather, it is a necessary expression of fidelity to Christ's mission to address injustice and promote a culture of love and life . Bishops, in union with the Pope, guide the faithful in applying Gospel values to societal problems, striving to build a just and compassionate social order .