After elections, ‘our concerns will remain the same’ on migration, USCCB president says
USCCB leaders said their advocacy for humane immigration policies will continue after the midterm elections, regardless of the new political landscape. Archbishop Paul S. Coakley said the bishops remain concerned about migrants’ dignity, mass deportations, detention conditions, and access to pastoral care. Bishop Daniel E. Flores emphasized due process and access to legal counsel for people navigating the immigration system. The bishops hope the incoming Congress will reopen discussion of immigration reform that respects national sovereignty and establishes orderly processes for asylum and immigration.
4 jam yang lalu
Following the midterm elections, U.S. Catholic bishops said they would continue pressing lawmakers from both parties for immigration policies that protect migrants’ dignity and due-process rights, address detention conditions, and create an orderly system for asylum and immigration. USCCB leaders said they were willing to work with the incoming Congress and administration regardless of which party holds power.
Archbishop Paul S. Coakley, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, said the bishops’ concerns would remain largely unchanged. He cited the treatment of migrants, the administration’s mass-deportation policies, conditions in detention centers, and access to pastoral and spiritual care in detention.
Bishop Daniel E. Flores, the conference’s vice president, emphasized due process, including the opportunity for people to defend themselves and obtain legal counsel in what he described as a complicated and intimidating migration system. He said these concerns were reflected in a special pastoral message on immigration approved at the bishops’ previous fall assembly.
Flores said the bishops have called for immigration-system reform for decades, seeking to respect national sovereignty while providing an orderly process for asylum and immigration. He said the system had been “frozen in time” and that the bishops hoped a renewed discussion might be possible.
The statements came after Democrats’ major midterm gains: they were projected to win a House majority of more than 80 seats and to hold at least 55 Senate seats. In the days after the election, President Donald Trump initially suggested his immigration approach may have been “too tough” and said he was open to working with Democrats, before his administration indicated deportations would continue.
Coakley said the bishops would work with whoever holds office and seek to shape public policy according to Catholic social teaching, the common good, and respect for human dignity.
Catholic social thought on migrant dignity and national sovereignty
Catholic social thought holds together two truths: migrants possess an equal, inalienable human dignity that governments must respect, and political authorities have a real responsibility to regulate migration for the common good. National sovereignty is therefore neither an absolute license to disregard migrants nor something the Church treats as meaningless. It is a responsibility to govern humanely, protect the rights of citizens and newcomers, and respond prudently to the needs of both.
A migrant’s dignity comes from being a human person, not from citizenship, legal status, country of origin, or religion. The Church therefore rejects treating migrants as less worthy of protection or participation because they are foreigners. Dignitas Infinita emphasizes that migrants have fundamental, inalienable rights that must be respected “in every circumstance,” and identifies welcoming them as one way of defending human dignity.
This principle does not mean that every migrant has a right to settle in any country of choice. It does mean that border and immigration policies must be judged by how they treat people, especially those who are poor or vulnerable. Pope Francis warned that a state’s rule of law is tested by dignified treatment of those at society’s margins; regulating orderly and legal migration is compatible with that duty, but policies cannot be built on the privilege of some and the sacrifice of others.
The Church also cautions against political rhetoric that turns migrants into a faceless threat. Fear can be exploited in ways that encourage xenophobia and obscure migrants’ equal dignity. At the same time, recognizing human dignity does not require denying that migration raises serious practical and social questions.
The Catechism gives political authorities a legitimate role in setting conditions for immigration. It says that prosperous countries should welcome foreigners seeking security and livelihood “to the extent they are able,” while authorities may regulate immigration for the common good and require immigrants to respect the country’s laws and contribute to civic life.
This is a qualified account of sovereignty. A state may control its borders, establish legal procedures, and address abuses; these responsibilities are not opposed to Catholic teaching. John Paul II specifically joined the state’s responsibility to control migration flows with the duty to respect immigrants’ fundamental rights, and said acceptance should comply with law while abuses are suppressed when necessary.
But sovereignty is not an unlimited moral permission. The nation’s interests must be considered within a broader understanding of the common good, which includes the dignity and rights of migrants as well as the rights of citizens. Fratelli Tutti describes a receiving society’s moral task as balancing these responsibilities rather than treating one as automatically cancelling the other.
Nor does the Church equate patriotism with hostility to outsiders. Pope Francis argues that the nation-state cannot be treated as an island, since nations are shaped by successive waves of migration and face challenges that require cooperation. He also recognizes subsidiarity: nations should exercise the responsibilities they can fulfill, while cooperating with other nations and institutions on shared problems.
Catholic teaching recognizes duties on both sides. Immigrants are called to respect the receiving country’s laws and heritage and to contribute to its civic burdens. Governments, in turn, must consider the human needs of people seeking safety or a livelihood, alongside the common good and the receiving society’s capacity.
Circumstances also matter. People fleeing persecution, life-threatening danger, or forced displacement may be unable to use ordinary visa pathways. The USCCB’s explanation of Catholic teaching notes that such dangers can give rise to a human right to seek protection through irregular means. That qualification does not make every irregular crossing morally identical; it recognizes that a person escaping grave danger may face a different moral situation from someone pursuing ordinary migration for other reasons.
Likewise, the Church’s concern is not limited to admission at the border. Migrants should be protected, promoted, and integrated. Integration means sharing in the life of a new homeland without requiring the erasure of a migrant’s personal history or identity; migrants, too, have duties to participate in the receiving society.
The Catholic approach is not simply “open borders” or “close borders.” It calls for policies that respect human dignity, regulate migration prudently, and protect the common good. The available teaching supports both lawful regulation and a serious obligation to attend to migrants’ needs; it does not prescribe a single numerical limit or one detailed immigration system for every country. Decisions about particular laws and policies therefore require prudential judgment, but they remain answerable to moral principles.
The same approach looks beyond the receiving country. Benedict XVI calls for cooperation between countries of origin and destination, supported by international norms that protect migrants and their families while also taking host countries’ needs into account. He insists that migrant workers must not be treated merely as commodities or as units of labor.
In short, national sovereignty is legitimate when exercised as responsible care for the common good—not when invoked to deny migrants’ humanity. Migrant dignity does not eliminate a state’s authority to regulate entry; state authority does not erase the duty to treat migrants as persons with rights. Catholic social thought asks governments and citizens to hold those claims together in policies that are lawful, prudent, and humane.