Brazil archbishop establishes rules for use of AI in archdiocesan communications
Archbishop Josafá Menezes da Silva of Aracaju issued guidelines for AI use in archdiocesan communications, stressing truth and human dignity. Guidelines mandate human review, labeling, and clear distinction of AI-generated content to prevent misrepresentation. Clergy are prohibited from using generative AI to recreate or simulate bishops, priests, or deacons’ faces or voices in a way that could be mistaken for authentic representation. The directives reference Pope Leo XIV’s encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, the 60th World Communications Day message, and the Holy See’s joint note Antiqua et Nova. They aim to ensure AI serves as an aid rather than a replacement for human responsibility in communication.
3 months ago
Archbishop Josafá Menezes da Silva of Aracaju, Brazil, has issued rules governing artificial intelligence in archdiocesan communications. The directive requires human oversight and transparency while prohibiting AI-generated images, audio, or statements that could falsely represent clergy or distort reality.
The guidelines apply to priests, deacons, lay ministers, communicators, and the faithful of the Archdiocese of Aracaju. They draw on Catholic teaching about human dignity, communications, and technology, including Pope Leo XIV’s message for the 60th World Communications Day, his encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, the Holy See’s Antiqua et Nova document, and a reflection by Father Doriano Vincenzo De Luca of the Archdiocese of Naples.
Menezes said the Church’s approach to AI must begin with the unconditional defense of human dignity. He emphasized that human intelligence should direct technology and that AI should assist, rather than replace, the responsible work of human beings.
All artwork produced with AI assistance must receive mandatory human review before publication.
The directive also requires AI-generated or AI-manipulated content to be labeled and clearly distinguished from material created by humans, particularly when the technology could affect how audiences understand the reality being presented.
The rules prohibit generative AI from reconstructing or simulating the appearance of a bishop, priest, or deacon when the result replaces an actual photograph or could be mistaken for an authentic depiction of the person or an event they experienced.
AI may not be used to simulate a clergy member’s voice in a message or speech that the person did not actually deliver. The directive also forbids attributing to a real person an appearance, statement, action, or situation that does not correspond to reality.
Specific prohibited practices include:
The archbishop permits AI as an auxiliary tool for nine types of creative work:
These uses remain subject to the directive’s requirements for human review, truthful representation, and disclosure where appropriate.
Menezes connected the rules to Pope Leo XIV’s warning that AI simulations can create “parallel realities,” appropriate people’s faces and voices, and make it harder to distinguish fact from fiction.
He also cited risks including digital fraud, cyberbullying, deepfakes, privacy violations, and unauthorized intrusion into personal intimacy. The directive therefore calls for protection of people’s images, photographs, recordings, faces, and voices.
The archbishop urged pastoral workers, communicators, and the faithful to use technology prudently, consult their respective ordinaries, and comply with applicable regulations.
He concluded that Church communications must be truthful in content and responsible in how people and events are represented, so that technology serves the Church’s mission without distorting it.
How should the Catholic Church regulate AI to safeguard truth and dignity?
The Catholic Church should regulate AI according to a human-centred, truth-oriented, and common-good framework. AI must remain a tool governed by human reason and moral responsibility—not an authority that replaces conscience, human judgment, or legitimate social institutions.
Every person is made in God’s image and possesses an irreducible dignity that does not depend on usefulness, productivity, intelligence, or social status. Therefore, no AI system may treat people merely as data, consumers, risks, or instruments.
Pope Francis’s principle is decisive:
“The inherent dignity of each human being and the fraternity that binds us together as members of the one human family must undergird the development of new technologies and serve as indisputable criteria for evaluating them before they are employed.”
Regulation should consequently prohibit or strictly limit AI uses that:
Truth is not merely a technical property; it is necessary for freedom and authentic community. The Church teaches that people have a duty to seek, adhere to, and live according to truth, while rejecting duplicity and hypocrisy.
Because AI can produce convincing falsehoods, regulation should require:
The USCCB specifically warns that deepfakes and manipulated political information contribute to a “growing crisis of truth” and therefore insists upon human oversight, accountability, and transparency.
This does not mean that every algorithm must be completely intelligible to every user. It does mean that those who deploy AI must be able to explain its purpose, limitations, data sources, foreseeable risks, and decision-making effects to regulators and affected persons.
AI cannot possess moral responsibility in the human sense. It does not have a conscience, personal dignity, or the capacity to answer morally before God and society. Responsibility therefore must never be transferred to “the algorithm.”
Human oversight should be:
In healthcare, education, employment, policing, welfare, and immigration, people should retain the right to human review and appeal. Automated decisions should not be final where they affect fundamental rights or a person’s livelihood.
AI can infer intimate patterns about a person’s behaviour and thinking from very limited data. For this reason, privacy is not simply a consumer preference but a safeguard for human dignity and the relational nature of the person.
Catholic regulation should therefore require:
Surveillance should be subject to judicial, democratic, and independent oversight. Security concerns do not automatically justify unlimited access to private life.
Freedom is not merely the absence of restraint; it is the capacity to pursue what is true and good. Catholic social teaching therefore rejects both coercive control and manipulation that secretly directs a person’s choices.
AI platforms should not be designed primarily to exploit addiction, anger, fear, loneliness, or compulsive attention. Users should have genuine control over personalization, recommendations, notifications, and the use of their data.
The principle of subsidiarity is especially relevant: persons and local communities should remain protagonists in decisions affecting their lives, rather than being controlled by distant corporations or centralized bureaucracies.
Regulation should thus promote:
AI may increase productivity, but economic efficiency cannot be the sole measure of progress. Human work has inherent dignity because it proceeds from the person and is ordered toward the person.
Regulation should address:
AI should assist workers rather than automatically render them disposable. Businesses should be held responsible for humane job design, fair compensation, training, and socially responsible governance.
The stronger the possible effect on life, rights, or social participation, the stronger the regulation should be. Particular safeguards are needed in:
The US bishops warn that automated systems can reinforce existing bias or introduce a purely utilitarian approach lacking essential human consideration.
AI regulation should also consider energy consumption, access to resources, and unequal distribution of benefits. Catholic social teaching requires attention both to “the cry of the earth” and “the cry of the poor.”
The Church should support policies that:
The Church should apply these principles internally by requiring human review of AI-generated pastoral, educational, administrative, and communications content. AI should never replace pastoral accompaniment, sacramental ministry, spiritual direction, or the personal discernment of a competent human being.
Catholic institutions should establish governance policies covering:
A Catholic approach does not reject AI. It welcomes technological creativity when it genuinely serves human flourishing, but rejects the idea that whatever is technically possible is therefore morally acceptable. Regulation should make truth, human dignity, freedom, solidarity, subsidiarity, accountability, and the common good the binding conditions of AI development and use.