In "My Son, the Priest," author Kristin Grady Gilger recounts the long and winding road of accepting her son's Jesuit vocation — and what that meant for her own faith.,In "My Son, the Priest," author Kristin Grady Gilger recounts the long and winding road of accepting her son's Jesuit vocation — and what that meant for her own faith.
1 day ago
A new article explores the personal narrative of a feminist mother whose relationship with her Jesuit son leads to her renewed Catholic faith.1
The piece, published on March 14, 2026, highlights this family dynamic as central to the story.1
The mother's feminist background contrasts with her son's vocation as a Jesuit, creating a compelling interplay.1
This suggests themes of reconciliation between progressive views and traditional religious commitment.1
The title frames the mother's journey as one of "rekindled" Catholicism, implying a return to faith influenced by her son.1
It positions the story as inspirational for those navigating similar personal or familial faith challenges.1
How does the Catholic Church reconcile feminist theology with traditional Jesuit spirituality?
The Catholic Church does not seek to reconcile radical or secular feminist theology—which often employs a "hermeneutics of suspicion" to challenge core doctrines like Christology, the maleness of Jesus, Trinitarian imagery, and the male priesthood—with traditional Jesuit spirituality, which emphasizes obedience to the Magisterium, discernment in light of Church teaching, and contemplation of Christ crucified. Instead, the Church promotes a "new feminism" that affirms the equal dignity of women, their unique "genius," and sexual complementarity, while firmly rejecting ideologies that undermine divine revelation or the Church's constitution. This approach aligns with Jesuit principles of fidelity to the faith and the Spiritual Exercises' call to surrender one's will to Christ's.
Feminist theology, as described in Catholic scholarship, typically begins with a critique rooted in suspicion toward Scripture and Tradition, viewing them as tainted by patriarchal biases. Gloria L. Schaab's summary exemplifies this methodology:
Critique in the feminist theological process begins with a "hermeneutics of suspicion" that is wary of underlying prejudices and presuppositions that exclude women's perspectives. During this stage of the process, oppressive texts are demythologized, exclusive male symbolism for the divine is exposed, dualisms of body and spirit are rejected, and hierarchical understandings of power are destabilised.
This leads to reconstructing doctrines, such as challenging the maleness of Jesus in Christology and soteriology, the doctrine of the Cross (seen as symbolizing victimization), and Trinitarian symbolism based on "hierarchical gender models," which feminists deem subversive to women as imago Dei. Such approaches contribute to what theologian Tracey Rowland calls post-conciliar "gnoseological concupiscence," prioritizing cultural forms over Christ.
Magisterial documents echo this critique. Pope John Paul II distinguished "radical feminism," which "seeks the rights of women by attacking and denying fundamental, clear and constant moral teaching," from the true dignity exemplified by Mary. He warned that extreme forms undermine the faith itself, promoting nature worship or myths over Christ, and are encouraged by some religious despite contradicting Gospel teaching. Similarly, radical strains dissolve sexual difference into cultural constructs, as in Rosemary Radford Ruether's view that maleness and femaleness are mere "reproductive role specialization" with no biological tie to psychological or social roles.
These critiques highlight incompatibility with Catholic anthropology, which upholds sexual dimorphism as integral to the imago Dei and complementarity.
Jesuit spirituality, drawn from St. Ignatius's Spiritual Exercises, centers on "interior knowledge of the Lord" through contemplation, colloquies "heart to heart" with Christ, and the "Contemplation to Attain Love," culminating in surrendering "memory, understanding, and will" to God. It fosters discernment amid worldly "confusion and multiplicity," combating subjectivism, relativism, and hedonism by adhering to the Magisterium.
Pope Benedict XVI urged Jesuits to defend "key points" of doctrine under secular attack, including "sexual morality, of marriage and the family," while exploring them in contemporary contexts without causing "confusion and dismay" among the faithful. This obedience mirrors Ignatius's prayer: "Take, Lord, and receive all my liberty, my memory, my understanding, and my entire will." Pope Francis emphasized entering Christ's pierced heart and daily examen for self-discipline.
Such spirituality demands harmony with the Church's "integral truth and unity," rejecting ambiguities that obscure apostolic identity.
Feminist theology's challenges clash directly with both Catholic doctrine and Jesuit fidelity:
Pope John Paul II rejected such polarization as a "faulty ecclesiology" raising "false hopes."
| Key Tensions | Feminist Theology Position | Catholic/Jesuit Response |
|---|---|---|
| Priesthood | Women must be ordained for equality | Definitive: Reserved to men; women's genius affirmed elsewhere |
| God-Language | Reject male imagery; promote feminine "Sophia" | Trinitarian fidelity; Mary as exemplar |
| Sexual Difference | Cultural construct; no binary | Complementarity as "precious asset" |
| Discernment | Suspicion of Tradition | Obedience to Magisterium via Exercises |
The Church reconciles genuine concern for women's dignity with Tradition via John Paul II's "new feminism," which rejects imitating "male domination" and affirms women's "genius" (e.g., motherhood, receptivity). This assimilates positive feminist insights—equal dignity, public participation—without doctrinal rupture, as in Mulieris Dignitatem.
Sexual difference is ontological: men and women equally actualized in intellect/will, yet feminine potency mirrors Marian receptivity. Complementarity, despite critiques, draws from Scripture and Tradition. Jesuit spirituality supports this through discernment of "signs of the times" faithful to doctrine.
Programs rejecting "patriarchy" for "divine feminine" or alternative liturgies betray this, promoting secular ideologies over Ignatian obedience.
The Catholic Church reconciles by rejecting radical feminist theology's subversion of doctrine while embracing a feminism harmonious with Tradition—one celebrating women's dignity, complementarity, and Marian exemplar. Traditional Jesuit spirituality facilitates this via discernment, examen, and Magisterial fidelity, ensuring the Exercises lead souls to Christ, not cultural ideologies. This preserves the faith's integrity amid modern challenges.