Green Light for Abortion in a Small Country Whose Head of State Is a Catholic Bishop
Andorra’s government approved a draft law decriminalizing women who undergo voluntary abortions, removing the current penalty of up to six months in prison. The bill still requires expedited approval by Parliament to amend Article 117 of the Penal Code. The draft keeps abortion prohibited within Andorra and preserves penalties for healthcare professionals who perform it, including up to three years in prison and five years’ disqualification. The Holy See has held discreet discussions in Andorra in defense of life.
4 hours ago
Andorra’s government has approved a bill that would remove criminal penalties for women who obtain abortions, while keeping abortion itself prohibited in the country and retaining penalties for providers. The proposal still requires parliamentary approval and could put the country’s two co-princes—one of them a Catholic bishop—in differing positions over its promulgation.
The draft would amend Article 117 of Andorra’s Penal Code, removing the current possibility of up to six months in prison for women who undergo an abortion. It would not authorize abortions in Andorra: providers would continue to face up to three years in prison and a five-year professional disqualification.
The procedure would also remain outside the services funded by Andorra’s Social Security Fund, and therefore excluded from public healthcare coverage. Supporters of abortion legalization have criticized the proposal as insufficient because it preserves the ban on procedures in Andorran medical facilities and provides no public funding.
Andorra is governed as a co-principality, with the Bishop of Urgell and the President of France serving as co-princes. The Bishop, Josep-Lluís Serrano Pentinat, could refuse to ratify the bill, while the French co-prince could authorize its promulgation; the government says Andorran legal mechanisms could allow the law to take effect with the approval of only one co-prince.
The article reports that Cardinal Pietro Parolin met Andorran officials in July 2026 to discuss decriminalization, and that the adopted approach accords with a formula reportedly agreed with the Holy See. Minister Ladislau Baró characterized the contacts as “institutional dialogue,” not formal negotiations, and the Holy See has not publicly endorsed the text.
The Council of Ministers approved the draft on October 28, and the government intends it to proceed through an expedited parliamentary process. Officials have presented the reform as compatible with the constitution and the continued operation of the co-principality, while arguing that constitutional protection of life need not require criminalizing women.
Catholic teaching shapes civil limits on abortion
Catholic teaching holds that civil law should protect unborn human life from conception, because the right to life is not granted by the state or by a majority vote. Applied to the reported Andorran proposal, that principle raises a serious concern: removing a legal penalty for women who undergo abortion may weaken the law’s protection of unborn children. But the news summary does not establish whether the draft would also change the legal status of abortion providers or other restrictions, so its full legal and moral implications cannot be determined from that summary alone.
The Catholic argument is not simply that the state should enforce every religious or moral teaching. It begins with a claim about human dignity and the common good: every innocent human being has an inherent right to life, and public authority has a duty to recognize and protect fundamental rights. The Catechism says that this right belongs to every human being “from the moment of conception until death” and warns that excluding a category of people from legal protection undermines equality before the law.
In Evangelium Vitae, John Paul II explains that civil law has a narrower role than moral law: it cannot replace conscience or regulate every moral matter. But it must defend fundamental rights, foremost among them the right to life of every innocent person. A law may sometimes tolerate conduct when prohibiting it would cause a graver harm; the encyclical distinguishes that limited toleration from declaring the violation of another person’s basic right to be a legitimate right.
The Church also presents this as a reason accessible to public debate, not as an attempt to impose a narrowly confessional rule. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith says that public law should respect fundamental moral norms in matters of human life, while the Church’s contribution is to defend values knowable through human reason and shared by people of good will.
Catholic teaching distinguishes the moral status of abortion from the best legal response to it. Direct abortion—intended as an end or as a means—is held to be gravely wrong because it deliberately kills an innocent human being. The CDF restates John Paul II’s teaching that no purpose, circumstance, or law can make such an act morally licit.
That does not mean the Church’s sources specify one detailed criminal code, identical penalties, or a single enforcement strategy for every country. The Catechism says law should provide “appropriate penal sanctions” for deliberate violations of the unborn child’s rights, but it does not set out a particular sentence or prescribe precisely how criminal liability should be allocated among the pregnant woman, providers, or others. The available material therefore supports the general principle that the law should protect unborn life and should not treat its deliberate destruction as a protected entitlement; it does not, by itself, settle the precise design of Andorra’s proposed law.
That distinction matters when assessing a bill described as “decriminalizing women.” Decriminalization is not necessarily the same legal change as making abortion generally lawful, but the summary does not provide enough detail to say what protections, prohibitions, or penalties the draft would retain. From the Catholic perspective, the key questions would include whether the bill continues to recognize the unborn child as a rights-bearing human being, whether abortion itself remains prohibited, and what legal protections and sanctions remain for deliberate violations.
Catholic teaching recognizes that legislatures may face an imperfect choice when an unjust law cannot immediately be repealed. John Paul II says that where a permissive abortion law cannot be overturned or completely abrogated, a public official who is firmly opposed to abortion may support proposals that limit the harm and reduce the law’s negative effects. That is presented as an effort to restrict an existing evil, not as approval of abortion.
This qualification does not erase the Church’s opposition to abortion laws. The same passage says officials must not promote or vote for laws that attack human life, while allowing a carefully limited harm-reduction approach when full repeal is unattainable. The CDF similarly says that Catholic legislators have a grave obligation to oppose laws attacking human life, while recognizing the possibility of supporting measures that restrict an already-existing permissive law.
Consequently, the Catholic assessment of Andorra’s proposal cannot be made solely from the phrase “decriminalizing women.” If the proposal merely adjusts the treatment of women while preserving meaningful legal protection for the unborn, that would raise a different policy question from a measure that authorizes abortion or removes legal protection for unborn children more broadly. Even in a harm-reduction case, the Church’s sources do not treat abortion itself as morally acceptable.
The Church also stresses that law shapes public understanding. John Paul II warns that laws influence patterns of thought and behaviour, and that a law violating an innocent person’s natural right to life is unjust. He argues that protecting life requires more than removing unjust laws: public policy should also address pressures on families and mothers, including through support for family life and parenthood.
This is important in a debate about punishment. Concern for the unborn child does not make the mother’s hardship or distress irrelevant. The CDF acknowledges that abortion decisions may arise from tragic fears about health, family circumstances, or the child’s future, while maintaining that such circumstances do not justify directly killing an innocent human being. A Catholic policy response therefore includes both legal protection for unborn life and practical assistance to women and families; the supplied sources do not establish which supports Andorra’s proposal includes.
For Catholics, then, the governing principle is that civil law should not deny unborn children the protection owed to them as human beings. Whether Andorra’s draft violates that principle in a particular way depends on its actual provisions, which the news summary does not specify. The Church’s teaching is clear about the end—protection of unborn life—and permits prudential debate about how law can best limit harm without treating abortion as a legitimate right.