How a new Israeli law is redefining education—and survival, for the worse—in Palestinian Christian schools
Teaching has become a critical lifeline in Palestinian territories as most other economic sectors, including tourism and work permits in Israel, have collapsed since the war began. The Israeli Knesset passed a law barring graduates from Palestinian Authority-accredited universities from teaching in Israeli schools without obtaining separate Israeli certification. Supporters of the law claim it safeguards against incitement, but critics, like Father Ibrahim Faltas, view it as severely destabilizing to Palestinian society. The new legislation directly impacts educators from institutions like Bethlehem University and Hebron University, many of whom are essential wage earners for their families. Christian educational institutions, such as the 18 schools run by the Custody of the Holy Land, form a diverse ecosystem serving Christian, Muslim, and Jewish students.
about 1 month ago
Teaching has become the primary source of income amid collapsed sectors like tourism and halted work permits to Israel.1
Public salaries from the Palestinian Authority have stopped, leaving teachers as key wage earners for families.1
On January 21, Israel's Knesset passed a law by 31-10 votes, barring graduates of Palestinian Authority-accredited universities from teaching in Israeli schools without Israeli certification.1
Promoted by Likud lawmakers Amit Halevi and Avichay Boaron, it aims to prevent incitement, though critics call it discriminatory.1
The Custody of the Holy Land runs 18 schools, including five in Jerusalem serving 12,000 students, many Muslim.1
235 educators from Bethlehem, Hebron, and Ramallah commute daily; without access, schools face closure due to lack of local qualified staff.1
Around 10,000 students missed classes post-Christmas when permits for 171 teachers were not renewed, leading to a strike.1
Permits were eventually granted for all days after protests, but the new law heightens fears despite not applying retroactively to current hires.1
The law threatens 235 families' survival, potentially accelerating Palestinian emigration and weakening Christian institutions promoting coexistence.1
Father Ibrahim Faltas emphasizes the Franciscan mission of peace, starting days with St. Francis' prayer amid conflict.1
Investigate Catholic Church’s stance on Israeli educational restrictions
The Catholic Church consistently upholds the right to education as a fundamental aspect of human dignity, particularly in regions marked by conflict like the Holy Land, where access to schooling can be hindered by occupation, checkpoints, and security measures. While the provided sources do not directly address specific "Israeli educational restrictions"—such as limitations on Palestinian school access, curricula controls, or closures due to military actions—they offer a broader framework emphasizing Catholic educational missions, diplomatic efforts to protect Church institutions, and calls for peace that indirectly safeguard educational opportunities for all, including Palestinians and Israeli citizens. Pope Leo XIV's recent writings stress education as a "laboratory of discernment" amid inequalities, while historical papal addresses and U.S. bishops' statements highlight the need to end barriers like checkpoints that exacerbate poverty and hopelessness, potentially impacting schooling.
Pope Leo XIV, in his Apostolic Letter Drawing New Maps of Hope marking the 60th anniversary of Gravissimum Educationis, portrays Catholic education not as a "nostalgic refuge" but as a prophetic response to modern crises, including "social insecurity and inequalities [that] can extinguish desire." This vision resonates in the Holy Land context, where educational access is strained. The Pope urges educational communities to "disarm words, raise your eyes, and safeguard the heart," prioritizing relationships over polemics and fostering hope through Gospel fidelity. Though not Israel-specific, this mandate implies a Church commitment to innovative pedagogy that counters fragmentation from hyper-digitalization or relational crises—issues amplified in conflict zones.
The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) similarly frames education within Holy Land advocacy, noting how Israeli security measures like "numerous check-points within the West Bank, and construction of a security wall deep in Palestinian areas have contributed to a dramatic decline in the Palestinian economy, deepening poverty and rising Palestinian anger and hopelessness." Such conditions indirectly restrict education by limiting movement, economic viability, and family stability, prompting the USCCB to demand an end to occupation for a viable Palestinian state where basic rights, including schooling, can flourish.
Papal diplomacy underscores protections for Catholic schools in Israel. Pope John Paul II, addressing Israel's first ambassador in 1994, stressed collaboration beyond diplomacy, including "a trusting relationship between the Israeli authorities and the different institutions of the Catholic Church present in the territory of the Holy Land." This laid groundwork for the 1993 Fundamental Agreement, aimed at juridical instruments supporting Church life, such as schools for Catholic faithful who are Israeli citizens.
In 1997, John Paul II welcomed Israel's ambassador, expressing hope for swift ratification of a "Legal Agreement" as "a most significant juridical instrument for the life of the Catholic Church in Israel," enabling equal partnership in society-building regardless of faith. These agreements implicitly defend educational freedoms, as Church schools serve diverse populations amid tensions.
The Church's stance ties education to peace. John Paul II's 2000 message to Holy Land bishops affirmed that Israelis and Palestinians "have the right to live in their own homes in dignity and security," urging a return to negotiations "on an equal footing and with respect for international law." He encouraged Christian leaders to promote mutual respect, appealing to Jewish and Muslim authorities for peace energies rooted in faith—essential for stable educational environments.
Recent voices echo this. Archbishop Paul Richard Gallagher in 2023 noted the Holy See's focus on Holy Places and the Christian community's "uninterrupted and constant presence," lamenting stalled Oslo Accords progress and Israel's "heavy-handed and militarily invasive attitude," which weakens Palestinians' position. The USCCB's 2016 Atlanta Summit affirmed a two-state solution, decrying occupation beyond 1967 borders and settlement expansions as threats to peace, while calling to protect Palestinian Christians—"living stones"—whose emigration is fueled by conflict, including barriers to opportunities like education.
Pope Leo XIV's 2025 press conference en route to Lebanon touched on Gaza amid Türkiye's two-state advocacy, signaling ongoing Vatican concern for conflict zones where education suffers.
Sources converge on non-violence, security for Israel alongside Palestinian statehood, Jerusalem's shared status protecting worship freedoms (relevant for faith-based schools), and resource equity like water. More recent documents, like Leo XIV's, take precedence, prioritizing hope-filled education over division. No source endorses unilateral restrictions; instead, they critique occupation's humanitarian toll without overreaching into specifics like school closures or UNRWA bans.
In summary, while lacking direct commentary on Israeli educational restrictions, Catholic sources advocate robustly for peace, rights, and Church protections that foster education for all in the Holy Land, viewing it as integral to justice and hope.