Indiana archbishop gives Mass dispensation amid ICE fears
Archbishop Charles C. Thompson of Indianapolis issued a dispensation exempting parishioners in the archdiocese from Mass attendance for the rest of September amid a surge in ICE enforcement. The decree was prompted by increased fear and anxiety among immigrant families, especially Hispanic Catholics, due to potential detentions and family separations. The dispensation applies to all residents of the archdiocese who reasonably fear detention, separation, or intimidation, even if they have legal documentation. The decision reflects the archdiocese’s commitment to pastoral care and protection of dignity for vulnerable communities during heightened immigration enforcement.
2 months ago
Archbishop Charles C. Thompson of Indianapolis has temporarily dispensed Catholics who fear immigration detention, family separation, or intimidation from the obligation to attend Sunday and holy-day Masses. The measure took effect September 4 and remains in force through September 30, making Indianapolis the seventh U.S. diocese reported to have issued a comparable decree amid heightened federal immigration-enforcement activity. 1 2
The dispensation applies to people living within the Archdiocese of Indianapolis who reasonably fear being detained, separated from their families, or intimidated because of increased immigration enforcement. It applies regardless of immigration status, including to people with valid legal documentation. 1 2
Thompson said the enforcement surge had generated fear and uncertainty, particularly because detention can abruptly separate parents and children. While acknowledging the role of law enforcement in protecting communities, he said families should be defended and every person treated with dignity, compassion, and respect. 1 2
The archdiocese said the decision followed requests from pastors working with immigrant communities. Communications director Sally Krause said the dispensation was intended to express the Church’s solidarity with people who were afraid to leave their homes. 2
Under canon law, a diocesan bishop or pastor may grant a dispensation from the Sunday Mass obligation for a just cause. The reports also note that every U.S. diocese and archdiocese issued Mass dispensations during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. 2
Thompson encouraged Catholics using the dispensation to pray with the Sunday Lectionary readings, pray the rosary or other sacramentals, and watch a livestreamed Mass. 1 2
He also asked pastors and other ministers to provide spiritual care, including access to the Sacraments of Penance and Anointing of the Sick and the distribution of Holy Communion to people who are homebound. 2
The decree is limited to one month, reflecting the archdiocese’s practice of assigning dispensations a defined period of legal force. Officials said the situation would be reassessed before deciding whether an extension was necessary. 1 2
The action followed reports of a substantial increase in ICE activity in Indianapolis and central Indiana during the week before Labor Day. The enforcement activity was associated with fear in immigrant communities, business closures, and the cancellation of a Latino festival. 1
The Archdiocese of Indianapolis has an extensive Hispanic ministry, serving a Catholic community in a state where nearly one-tenth of residents are Hispanic. 1
Indianapolis is described as the seventh U.S. diocese to issue a Mass dispensation specifically for migrants or other Catholics fearing deportation or immigration detention since the start of the Trump administration. The dioceses named in the reports are San Bernardino, Nashville, Columbus, New Orleans, Baton Rouge, Charlotte, and Indianapolis; together, they cover approximately 3.5 million Catholics. 1 2
San Bernardino Bishop Alberto Rojas issued the first formal dispensation of this type in July 2025. Nashville Bishop J. Mark Spalding advised Catholics that attending Sunday Mass should not come at the expense of their safety, while Columbus Bishop Earl K. Fernandes issued a comparable decree covering the period from late 2025 into January 2026. 1
Archbishop Jeffrey Grob of Milwaukee has said he would consider a dispensation if conditions in his archdiocese warranted one, but no such decree had been announced there. Bishops in El Paso, Brownsville, and Tucson have issued strong statements about migrant detention and deportation but have not granted comparable Mass dispensations. 2*
Catholic dispensation protects migrant dignity amid immigration enforcement
A Catholic dispensation can protect migrants from being forced to choose between Sunday Mass and personal safety during immigration enforcement—but it is not a blanket exemption from immigration law.
Under Catholic teaching, the Sunday Mass obligation admits exceptions for a serious reason, and the faithful may also be dispensed by their pastor. A diocesan bishop may dispense from universal or particular disciplinary laws when he judges that doing so benefits the faithful’s spiritual welfare; this authority does not extend to penal or procedural laws. Thus, if attending Mass would expose a migrant or family to a serious risk of arrest, separation, or other grave harm, the person may be excused from the obligation, though the precise pastoral judgment belongs to competent Church authority.
This does not mean that immigration officers are legally barred from enforcing civil law on church property. The supplied sources do not establish the current legal scope of any “sensitive locations” policy or a specific enforcement incident. Catholic teaching does, however, insist that border enforcement respect human dignity, humanitarian needs, family unity, and due process. Nations may regulate their borders, but that right must be balanced with duties toward migrants and refugees.
The broader Catholic principle is that migrants retain the same human dignity as everyone else. The Church therefore calls Catholics to defend migrants’ rights—even in cases of irregular immigration—and to offer pastoral welcome without confusing charitable assistance with approval of every form of unlawful entry.