Pope Leo helps Argentines embrace Francis, the pontiff who once divided them
Pope Leo XIV’s visit to Argentina drew large crowds, many of them young people, and helped Argentines celebrate the legacy of Pope Francis. Francis’s advocacy for the poor and criticism of political leaders made him a divisive figure at home, and he never returned to Argentina as pope. During Leo’s visit, political allies and opponents alike praised Francis, signaling a shift toward seeing him as a unifying national figure. Church leaders say Leo is continuing Francis’s priorities with a gentler style, building on the path his predecessor opened.
2 hours ago
Pope Leo XIV’s four-day visit to Argentina helped shift public attention toward the legacy of his predecessor, Pope Francis, whose criticism of economic inequality and engagement with social issues had made him a polarizing figure at home. Leo revisited Francis’s causes and places associated with him, while his less politically charged profile allowed those messages to reach Argentines across political divides.
As archbishop of Buenos Aires, Jorge Mario Bergoglio organized church support for poor communities during Argentina’s 2001 economic crisis, including soup kitchens, schools and drug-rehabilitation programs. He also criticized Peronist leaders and clashed with them over same-sex marriage, but as pope his critiques of unrestrained capitalism and his outreach to marginalized people drew support from Peronists and anger from conservatives.
Francis’s relationships with politicians were closely scrutinized, and his gestures toward presidents from different political camps were interpreted as signs of partisanship. Although he visited more than 60 countries, he never returned to Argentina as pope, despite invitations from four successive presidents; some observers said a homecoming would have placed him in the middle of the country’s political divisions.
Large crowds, including many young Argentines, gathered for Leo’s visit. At events, people carried signs linking the two popes, while Leo used the phrase “todos, todos, todos” and other language associated with Francis. Argentina’s President Javier Milei, who had previously insulted Francis, called him “the most important Argentine in history” at Leo’s welcome ceremony.
Leo described the trip as a homage to Francis and visited places central to his predecessor’s ministry, including Francis’s former cathedral, a prison where Francis had washed inmates’ feet, a disability-care home and the Luján shrine. He invoked Francis at least 26 times during the visit.
Leo also reiterated Francis’s appeals in his own words. In Córdoba, he urged young people to “make a mess,” echoing Francis’s call for young Catholics to shake up their dioceses. Speaking to garbage pickers and business leaders, he cited Francis’s “three Ts”—land, housing and work—and, in an address to political leaders, said the economy should serve people rather than people serving the economy.
Politicians from opposing camps sought to identify with themes raised during the visit. Peronist governor Axel Kicillof called the trip necessary “in these times of cruelty,” while Vice President Victoria Villarruel defended social justice, a concept Francis had championed and Milei had criticized. Milei’s spokesman, meanwhile, argued that the government’s success in reducing inflation had put the economy at people’s service.
Argentine clergy and observers described Leo as continuing Francis’s emphasis on peace, care for the poor and engagement with people in difficult circumstances, but in a gentler style. They also said Leo’s lack of an Argentine political identity made it harder to dismiss his statements about workers and vulnerable people as Peronist.
Prophetic concern for the poor can foster national reconciliation
The claim is persuasive in Catholic social teaching, provided “prophetic concern” means more than charitable relief: it means naming conditions that violate human dignity, urging just public remedies, and standing with people who are excluded or suffering. This can help reconcile a nation because peace is not simply the absence of conflict; it depends on justice, inclusion, and a shared commitment to the common good. But reconciliation must not become a demand that victims stay silent or accept injustice.
In addressing Argentina during a severe national crisis, St. John Paul II warned that social conditions could foster division, hatred, and resentment. He called the bishops to be “ministers of reconciliation,” while also urging them to speak courageously about just conditions of life, work, and housing. He connected the country’s future not to harmony at any cost, but to peace grounded in justice.
“the future of the country must be based on peace, the fruit of justice”
That connection matters. Where people lack necessities, lose their livelihoods, or believe that institutions serve only the powerful, social trust can erode. The Church’s concern for the poor can address these grievances without treating one class or group as an enemy: it insists that every person’s dignity and rights matter, and that public life should serve the whole people. In Nigeria, John Paul II similarly insisted that a nation’s resources should benefit everyone and rejected the intimidation or political exclusion of the poor and weak. He described justice, joined to love of neighbor and humble service, as key to resolving social conflicts.
A prophetic concern for the poor does not mean predicting the future. Here it means bearing moral witness: making visible suffering that society might prefer to ignore, and calling people and authorities to act justly. John Paul II told Argentina’s bishops to use “courageous and timely words” and to press those with political, administrative, and judicial responsibility to improve living, working, and housing conditions. He also praised practical Church efforts to assist people facing poverty, unemployment, and loss. The example joins public advocacy with immediate care rather than setting them against each other.
That witness can serve reconciliation because it challenges the marginalization of people in need. In his address to the bishops of Chile, John Paul II warned against social models that pass by those in need and treat the poorest as insignificant in the pursuit of progress, accumulation, and status. A society is more capable of genuine unity when the vulnerable are recognized as members whose needs and voices count, not as obstacles or leftovers.
Catholic teaching does not identify reconciliation with forgetting, suppressing grievances, or forcing victims to “move on.” Benedict XVI teaches that reconciliation can restore social unity and open a path to lasting peace, but he also says it requires a courageous and honest pursuit of responsibility for serious crimes. Victims have a right to truth and justice. Forgiveness and accountability, then, are not opposites: reconciliation seeks to heal relationships without hiding the wrongdoing that damaged them.
This is an important qualification to the claim. Concern for the poor fosters national reconciliation only when it is truthful and just. If appeals to unity silence those suffering from exploitation or exclusion, they preserve the conditions of resentment rather than heal them. Conversely, if concern for the poor becomes a pretext for hatred, vengeance, or denying the dignity of opponents, it also fails to reconcile. John Paul II described reconciliation as overcoming divisions through recognition of others as brothers and sisters, while explicitly rejecting domination and abuse of power.
The Church’s role is to call the whole society toward just conditions and humane relationships, not to substitute itself for citizens and public authorities. In Argentina, John Paul II emphasized that the people themselves must be principal agents in rebuilding their country, even while seeking help where needed. His account places responsibility on leaders to promote justice and on citizens to contribute to the common good.
Thus, prophetic concern for the poor can foster national reconciliation by bringing neglected suffering into public conscience, pressing for fairer conditions, and reminding divided groups that they share responsibility for the dignity of all. It does not guarantee unity, and the available texts do not claim that poverty alone explains national conflict. They support a more careful conclusion: reconciliation becomes more credible when a nation confronts injustice, protects the vulnerable, and pursues peace through truth, justice, and service.