Reports indicate growing criticism of Pope Francis from within the College of Cardinals, reflecting underlying tensions within the Catholic Church. Articles from America Magazine and the National Catholic Reporter highlight these attacks, with sources suggesting the Pope may even welcome the frankness. The criticism comes as the church navigates its future, with discussions about the upcoming conclave and the challenges it poses. These criticisms are viewed by some as part of a larger trend of authoritarianism.
15 days ago
Several cardinals have voiced criticisms of Pope Francis following his death, particularly during the pre-conclave period 1 2. Cardinal Beniamino Stella openly attacked Francis for "bypassing the long-standing tradition of the church" by opening governance positions to lay individuals 1. Other criticisms, often delivered anonymously, accuse Francis of modernism 2.
Pope Francis encouraged open and honest dialogue within the church, valuing "parrhesia," or frank speech 1. He urged bishops and cardinals to speak boldly and listen with humility 1. However, he strongly disapproved of gossip and behind-the-back complaints, preferring direct criticism 1.
Despite the criticisms, many cardinals and church leaders have defended Pope Francis's legacy 2. Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández emphasized Francis's tireless work ethic and dedication to the poor 2. Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich praised Francis's synodal approach, highlighting his commitment to listening and inclusivity 2. Billboards throughout Rome display images of Francis, expressing gratitude for his service 2.
Some analysts view the criticisms as a "political power play" to reclaim papal power and shift the church's direction 2. These critiques may represent an attempt to revert the changes implemented during Francis's papacy and restore a more traditional approach 2. The timing of the criticism, after Francis's death, has also been interpreted as a sign of disrespect 1.
The role of the Pope within the Catholic Church involves specific duties and responsibilities, and tensions may arise from varying interpretations and expectations.
Here's an overview of the Pope's role and how Catholics are called to respond to disagreements:
The Pope serves as the successor of Peter and the foundation of unity for the Catholic Church, possessing supreme authority in teaching and governance. When disagreements or criticisms arise, Catholics are called to respond with charity, avoiding slander and promoting dialogue, while also respecting Church authority and remaining faithful to tradition.