The U.S. Senate confirmed Brian Burch as the country's Vatican ambassador. Burch is a co-founder of CatholicVote, a political organization that supported Trump. The Senate vote was 49-44 along party lines. Burch has criticized Pope Francis in the past, citing a 'pattern of vindictiveness'.
16 days ago
Brian Burch, co-founder and former president of CatholicVote, a political organization that supported Donald Trump, has been confirmed by the U.S. Senate as the country's ambassador to the Holy See 1 2 3. The confirmation vote, held on August 2, 2025, was 49-44, largely along party lines 1 3. Burch, a Catholic father of nine from Chicago, expressed gratitude to President Trump and the Senate, stating his commitment to representing the administration and working with Vatican leaders to promote human dignity and the common good 1 3.
Burch's nomination by Trump on December 20, 2024, came despite his history as a vocal critic of Pope Francis 1. He has previously cited a "pattern of vindictiveness" in Francis and expressed offense at some of the pontiff's remarks, including comments about Catholics not needing to "breed like rabbits" 1. His confirmation had been delayed for several months, notably blocked in May by Senator Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) due to concerns over the Trump administration's closure of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) 1 3. Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-South Dakota) filed cloture on Burch's confirmation, ending the delay 3.
During his April 8 confirmation hearing before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Burch emphasized the "unique and vital" relationship between the U.S. and the Vatican, rooted in shared commitments to religious freedom, human dignity, global peace, and justice 1. He pledged to deepen this partnership, recognizing the Holy See's moral witness and global influence as key to U.S. interests 1. Burch also faced questions on foreign aid cuts, the China-Vatican agreement, and the Israel-Hamas conflict 3. He expressed support for refocusing foreign aid, committed to encouraging the Holy See to challenge Chinese government intervention in bishop elections, and believed the Vatican could play a significant role in ending the Israel-Hamas conflict and securing hostage releases 3.
Burch succeeds former Senator Joe Donnelly, a Democrat from Indiana, who served as Vatican ambassador from April 2022 until July 2024 1. Callista Gingrich held the position during Trump's first presidential term 1. Burch noted the "historic election of the first American pope," Pope Leo XIV, who is also from Chicago, as a remarkable coincidence 3. CatholicVote has since named Kelsey Reinhardt as its new president, with Reinhardt celebrating Burch's confirmation and his past leadership 3.
What is the Church's teaching on political engagement?
The Catholic Church teaches that political engagement is a moral obligation for all citizens, rooted in their baptismal commitment to follow Jesus Christ and bear Christian witness in all aspects of life . This participation is considered a virtue and a lofty vocation, one of the highest forms of charity, as it seeks the common good .
In essence, the Church views political engagement as an indispensable aspect of Christian life, a means by which the faithful contribute to the common good and bear witness to Christ's teachings in the public square. This engagement is to be characterized by moral integrity, a focus on human dignity, and a commitment to justice and charity, with distinct but complementary roles for clergy and laity.